Community management

Comment moderation for scholars whose videos attract sectarian arguments

We moderate comments on your YouTube, Facebook and TikTok against a written policy you approve: sectarian bait, abuse and spam hidden, genuine questions collected and passed to you, and nothing ever answered on a matter of faith in your name. The aim is a comment section where a sincere listener can still ask something.

On the Growth package, PKR 35,000 per month. Ad spend, if you run ads, is separate.

Ask on WhatsApp Get a free audit

Why it fits

Why community management matters for religious speakers and scholars

Under a video about salah, someone drops the maslak question purely to start a fight, and within an hour the comments are a battlefield that drowns the sincere questions. A scholar cannot sit and moderate that, and leaving it unmoderated tells new listeners the channel is a place for arguments. Moderation for this trade needs judgement more than speed: it must remove provocation without silencing honest disagreement, and it must never reply to a religious question on your behalf.

The work

What we run for religious speakers and scholars

Write a short comment policy with you, publish it on the channel, and pin it under videos on contested topics.
Hide sectarian provocation, abuse, spam and scam links across YouTube, Facebook and TikTok, using blocked-word lists in Urdu and Roman Urdu.
Collect sincere questions into a weekly list for you, which often becomes the next week's answer clips.
Escalate threats, impersonation accounts and coordinated attacks to you immediately, with screenshots saved.
Report impersonation pages using your name or photo, and keep a record of reports filed and their outcomes.

Examples

Where we would start

Illustrative starting points, not results. The audit decides the real first move.

Pinned comment

'Is channel par sawal ka khair maqdam hai. Kisi maslak ya shakhsiyat ke khilaf comments hata diye jaate hain. Apna sawal adab se likhein — chuninda sawalon ka jawab agle hafte diya jayega.'

Weekly question list

Every Thursday, a short document: the ten clearest questions from the week's comments, with links, grouped by topic. You choose which to answer; we cut those answers as next week's clips.

How do I deal with sectarian comments on my videos?

Publish a clear comment policy, hide provocation consistently and leave sincere disagreement visible. Scholars in Islamabad and Rawalpindi who moderate this way keep their comments usable for genuine questions. Arguing back rarely helps; a calm pinned policy and steady moderation do more than any reply you could write.

Should a religious speaker turn off comments?

Usually not, because comments carry the questions that guide your next bayan. Turning them off on a single provocative video can be sensible. For most speakers in the twin cities, active moderation with a published policy keeps the benefit of comments without letting arguments take over.

Pitfalls

Common mistakes with community management

Deleting every disagreement, which looks defensive and pushes critics to post the same thing on re-upload channels instead.
Letting an assistant reply 'JazakAllah' to everything, including comments that were actually sarcastic or hostile.

Where

Where religious speakers and scholars cluster in the twin cities

Price

What does community management for religious speakers and scholars cost?

The Growth package includes daily comment and DM replies on one or two platforms; very busy inboxes or replies on a third platform are quoted after we see a typical week.

Growth

PKR 35,000per month

A YouTube channel or business page that is posting but not growing.

4 long-form videos edited
12 Shorts, Reels or TikToks edited
Thumbnails for everything we publish
Full channel or page SEO
Comment and DM replies
Weekly report on WhatsApp
1 strategy call every month

Month to month. Cancel any time.
Ad spend is separate and paid straight to the platform. We never mark it up.
No setup fee, no hidden charges.
Prices are in PKR and include everything listed.

Compare every package

Questions about community management for religious speakers and scholars

These are the questions we get on WhatsApp every week, answered the way we would answer them there.

WhatsApp us

Will you answer questions in my comments?

No. We never answer a religious question for you. We collect them for you to answer, and only reply with neutral messages such as pointing to an existing video you have approved for that question.

Can moderators speak Urdu and understand the context?

Yes. Moderation is done in Urdu, Roman Urdu and English, and the blocked-word lists include the spellings people actually use to bait arguments, not just formal Urdu.